Tired of overpaying for a giving platform that still falls short? Discover the best Pushpay alternatives and find a platform that truly meets your church’s needs and budget.
Join the fundraising movement! Join the fundraising movement!
Add us as a preferred source on Google
The right giving platform should help your church grow, not hold it back. And when you’re working with a tight budget, that may mean looking at other options that give you more for less.
In this post, I’ll walk you through the best Pushpay alternatives, breaking down their pros and cons so you can make a confident decision for your church.
Many organizations start looking outside of Pushpay because they feel like they’re paying a premium price without getting the flexibility or features they actually need.
For example, tools like peer-to-peer fundraising and crowdfunding are very limited, and if you want to customize them, it often comes with extra fees or add-ons.
Key features, like in-person giving kiosks or certain payment options, aren’t always there, which can lead to missed donation opportunities.
Many users are also frustrated by Pushpay’s long-term contracts. Even a one-year commitment can feel restrictive for churches that need the freedom to pivot quickly if their needs change. That lack of flexibility is a major reason many teams start exploring other options.
Here’s what one Pushpay review has to say:
It is just in no way worth the cost! And the idea of being locked into annual contracts with so many services not requiring that is insane. – Anthony M.
Already made the decision to close your Pushpay account? Here’s how to cancel Pushpay in three simple steps.
Don’t let Pushpay limit what your fundraising can do. Take a look at these five alternatives that may be a better fit for your goals and budget.
Donorbox serves over 100,000 nonprofits and churches, with scalable giving solutions for ministries of all sizes.
While many church-focused giving platforms stick to basic online giving features, Donorbox goes further with more advanced fundraising tools. This includes peer-to-peer fundraising, email marketing, event ticketing, membership, and highly customizable online donation forms.
Donorbox places a strong emphasis on recurring giving, with donation forms designed to encourage consistent, reliable support for your ministries. This is especially helpful for churches trying to make the most of a tight budget.
Plus, Donorbox offers a dedicated pillar for churches, designed specifically to help churches like yours increase tithes.
Donorbox offers three pricing plans:
With every plan, supporters also have the option to cover the processing fees, so more of their donation goes directly toward your mission.
Bonus resource: Discover more reasons to choose Donorbox over Pushpay.
Tithely is an all-in-one giving platform built specifically for churches. It offers a range of digital giving options along with custom church websites and mobile apps to help you stay connected with your congregation.
Tithely offers three pricing plans for churches:
Transaction fees start at 2.9% + 30¢ per donation.
Givelify is another digital giving platform for churches, offering a mobile-first giving experience. Beyond just collecting gifts, Givelify also offers analytics tools like donation tracking, which give leaders a clearer picture of giving trends.
Givelify doesn’t charge signup or monthly fees, but there is a standard processing cost of 2.9% + $0.30 per credit card donation, with an additional fee for American Express transactions.
It also doesn’t clearly offer a donor-covered fee option, so churches may need to absorb those processing costs themselves.
easyTithe is a church-focused giving platform that makes it easy to accept donations through your website, mobile app, text messaging, and an in-person giving kiosk.
Outside of digital giving, easyTithe also helps you manage day-to-day church life through its app, with features like prayer requests, child check-in, and integrations with church management systems.
easyTithe doesn’t publicly list plan pricing on their website. Costs and processing fees vary depending on the size of your church, with additional features offered as paid add-ons, and a $10 minimum processing fee to keep in mind.
MinistryPlatform is a comprehensive church management system designed especially for larger congregations. It allows churches to manage members, volunteers, and donations all in one centralized platform.
It also includes a full suite of online giving tools such as embedded donation forms, QR codes, text-to-give, and even options for crypto and stock giving.
MinistryPlatform doesn’t publicly list its pricing. It operates on a subscription-based model with optional add-on products available depending on the needs of the church.
At the end of the day, the right platform comes down to what your church needs to grow. Some tools keep things simple, while others are built to help you expand and build long-term support.
If you’re looking for that balance, Donorbox is a strong Pushpay alternative worth exploring. Plus, Donorbox makes it easy to try for free and see if it’s the right fit!
For more platform comparisons or church fundraising tips, check out the rest of the Nonprofit Blog.
With a background in professional writing, Lydia brings over 10 years of experience in nonprofit communications under her belt, with a strong focus on fundraising and donor engagement. Her passion for supporting nonprofits was sparked during college internships with global mission organizations, where she gained hands-on experience with fundraising marketing strategies.
Lydia went on to serve for more than eight years as a Church Communications Director, overseeing both internal and external communications to clearly communicate the church’s mission, build trust with members, and encourage generosity through accessible tools like online and recurring giving. In this role, she partnered closely with church leadership to support giving campaigns and highlight the real-life impact of financial support through storytelling.
These experiences have continued to fuel her dedication to empowering nonprofits through her writing.
Join the fundraising movement! Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
