When you’re drowning in department requests, it feels like all you can do is get the asks and announcements out the door. But focusing on relationships in your email strategy builds a foundation that makes your high-priority messages more successful.
Join the fundraising movement! Join the fundraising movement!
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Does this sound familiar? Your volunteer, program, and marketing teams all have emails competing for space on the calendar. And they’re counting on you to make sure the messages land.
You’re left trying to punch the right buttons to trigger the right action, leaving your supporters feeling like ATMs.
Treating email as a relationship builder invites your supporters to be partners. A transactional lens gets short-term results. But a relationship-based reframe can power your mission much longer.
Focusing on relationships naturally boosts your transaction metrics. You will see better conversion, retention, and engagement rates.
People want to feel seen. Research by Professor Jen Shang at the Institute for Sustainable Philanthropy discovered that identity drives generosity. One of their case studies found that adding identity-based language to a donation form increased the response rate by 102%.
The same is true in the private sector. McKinsey’s 2021 Next in Personalization found that the value of personalization is multiplying, with 71% of consumers expecting it. As personalized experiences continue to become the norm, that number will only grow.
Humanizing your organization (not just your impact) also creates a deeper connection. People who identify with a brand’s community are more likely to be advocates and long-term supporters.
Your email strategy shouldn’t just talk to the donor. It should invite them into a community of people who share their values.
Focus on the humans on every side of your communications to make your email marketing strategy more relationship-based.
To do that, I work from this guiding principle: write from a person, write to a person, write about a person. If you haven’t been writing to your supporters this way yet, they’ll absolutely notice when you make the shift.
Give your supporters a human to connect with, not a faceless entity.
Use “I” statements to add credibility and authenticity. Always provide a real person’s email address for replies. Your supporters can then start a conversation, confident that someone’s on the other side.
Trade the nonprofit-speak for clear, conversational writing.
Keep the formatting simple – as if you were emailing a friend. Use large, easy-to-read fonts and plenty of white space. And add strategic bolding to guide readers and skimmers toward the action you hope they’ll take.
Center your communications on stories of your work, not organizational announcements.
Lift up the people your organization serves and those who work to serve them. Your stories are the heart of your work. They’ll give your supporters a much clearer sense of your impact than any statistic.
Be transparent with the people you feature in your stories. Let them know when and how you’ll use their story. And give them opportunities to give their approval or share their edits. They’re your supporters, too. Keeping their agency and dignity front and center strengthens that relationship.
Supporter journeys are useful tools, but they come with a catch. A journey’s structure suggests that a supporter’s interaction follows a predictable path. It also siloes their experiences (volunteer, donor, ticket buyer) when, in reality, it’s much messier.
Skip the straight path. Instead, focus on the different experiences and milestones supporters have with your organization:
Your goal should be to celebrate where they are and invite them to engage more deeply.
I’m sure you’ve seen nonprofit email programs that look like a cluttered coffee shop bulletin board. “Donate Now! Sign Up! Attend this Event!”
But if you’re always shouting through a megaphone instead of inviting conversation, your supporters will tune you out. Or kick you out of their inbox.
You may have heard the fundraising guideline to send seven thank yous for every ask. That philosophy should apply to your entire program. To build a real, balanced relationship with your supporters, you need to provide value more often than you request action. This includes:
You should also layer in emails focused on listening. Invite input. Use polls, surveys, or simple requests to “reply and share your story.”
I would bet money that none of your supporters see themselves as “Lapsed” or “Annual Fund” donors. How they see themselves in relation to your mission is what actually drives engagement. To understand this, use two tactics:
Effectively segmenting your audiences means your supporters won’t just read your emails. They’ll anticipate them and act on them.
Open rates aren’t that useful, as many are now triggered by robot scans from email providers before a human even sees the message. Clicks are stronger, but the golden metric is shifting.
As AI filters begin to anticipate user interest, the team at The Marketing Millennials noticed something: those who “treated email like a billboard are getting ignored by AI. The ones building actual relationships with their subscribers are winning harder than ever.”
So, “Opens matter less now, clicks matter more, replies matter MOST.” They are the strongest signal that your content is useful and relevant to the reader.
Even though it’s harder to track, don’t overlook qualitative data. Survey responses, personal anecdotes, and genuine replies are pop-the-confetti moments that prove your email marketing is resonating with donors.
You can’t be a personalized pen pal to every supporter, as nice as that would be. Instead, you’ll need to use automation and a centralized CRM to get a comprehensive picture of your supporters.
I once worked at an organization where the development database was separate from the program database. The disconnect was a liability. We had no idea how our donors interacted with the rest of the organization. Piecing together that information was time-consuming and full of data gaps.
Having centralized data enables you to recognize key moments. It also allows you to build a robust welcome series so you can learn about your supporters without draining your team’s resources.
Try to find an integrated CRM with email, like Donorbox’s email marketing platform (coming soon). Use automations triggered by milestones to save time. These personalized emails invite deeper engagement with every click.
The most successful nonprofit email strategy is just human relationship building at scale. Instead of optimizing your program for clicks and opens, optimize it for connection.
Because when you write emails that make your supporters feel like part of a community, the rest will fall into place.
Looking for a place to start? Donorbox Email Marketing tracks key moments for you. You get data-driven insights to send personal emails without the burnout. And, you can grab my Supporter Connection Cheat Sheet to help you write emails from a person, to a person, and about a person, every time.
Lee O’Connell is a copywriter & communications strategist with 10 years of experience helping nonprofits build supporter loyalty through elevated storytelling and genuine connection. She has a track record of boosting donor retention, moving annual fund donors to deeper engagement, and celebrating loyalty over gift size. Lee’s mission is to replace transactional nonprofit communications with real, mission-driven relationships.
Join the fundraising movement! Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
