See for yourself how easy fundraising can be with Donorbox.Watch the Demo now
How to Use AI Responsibly for Your Nonprofit: What NPO Leaders Should Know
Using AI responsibly can elevate efficiency and impact, strengthen donor trust, and protect the people and communities you serve – but only with the right guardrails in place.
Updated on : Shared an AI governance scorecard, sample AI disclosure statements, a tool-selection checklist, and an example of AI inaccuracies; updated the AI policy template
Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping the nonprofit sector. Whether it’s used to curate content or analyze fundraising data, AI can significantly streamline your workload and free up more time for mission-focused work.
Even so, studies show that only 24% of nonprofits have an AI policy in place. However your nonprofit staff plans to use AI, having a solid AI framework is crucial to protect your organization’s reputation, maintain compliance, and protect sensitive information.
Below, I’ll explain how to use AI ethically as a nonprofit, with a practical framework and free AI policy template to get you started.
What Does Responsible AI Mean for Nonprofits?
Responsible AI refers to the ethical and safe development and execution of AI systems.
For nonprofit leaders, this ensures that the AI platforms you leverage are trustworthy and used to support your overall mission while safeguarding the sensitive information of all involved – especially your donors.
The principles of responsible AI usage include:
Accountability: Be clear about who owns AI use in your nonprofit. This could be one person, a small team, or even an AI committee.
Fairness and inclusivity: AI tools often reflect bias, so they shouldn’t be used without careful review. Make sure different voices are involved when choosing and testing AI systems.
Transparency: Be open about how your nonprofit uses AI. For example, donors should know if AI is being used to support major reports or other processes.
Data privacy and security: Treat donor and organizational data with extreme care. Sensitive information should only be used in approved tools, with clear rules around how it’s protected and stored.
Human oversight: AI should support your team’s work, not replace human judgment. A human should always review AI-generated content, verify facts, and ensure all outputs align with your mission and values.
Now that I’ve explained the concept of responsible AI and its guiding principles, I’ll explain why it’s important to put precautions in place before using it.
Why Your Nonprofit Needs AI Guardrails
The trust and generosity of your donors, volunteers, and others in your community are fundamental to the success of your mission.
AI can create more room for productivity and innovation, but only when everyone knows how to use it safely. Clear guardrails make that possible while protecting sensitive data and the donor relationships you’ve worked so hard to build.
AI use often starts small, like a fundraiser drafting a donor email or your finance manager summarizing a lengthy report. But without clear guidelines, even everyday uses can expose your organization to risks such as:
Sharing sensitive donor information with AI tools that use that data for learning. Without any guidelines in place, staff may not know what information is appropriate to share and which approved AI tools to use.
Distributing incorrect information to staff and supporters, which can damage organizational credibility and erode trust.
Generic messaging that lacks authenticity and personalization, which can weaken donor relationships and counteract your fundraising goals.
Lack of accountability when staff use AI differently. This makes it challenging to know who’s responsible when problems arise.
Having a clear AI policy can support your team to use AI tools confidently and protect donor information and relationships.
How to Use AI Responsibly
Use the guidelines below to adopt AI responsibly across your organization.
1. Start with an AI use audit
Before creating an AI policy for your nonprofit, you need to understand how AI is already being used across your organization.
Share a simple survey with staff and volunteers to gather the feedback needed to shape your AI policy. Ask questions like:
Which AI tools are you using right now?
What tasks does AI help you streamline?
Do you input any donor, financial, beneficiary, and/or organizational information into AI tools?
Do you review any AI-generated content before using, sharing, or publishing it?
Which repetitive tasks do you feel AI can improve your efficiency with?
How do you think AI can be used to support fundraising?
Once you have an understanding of how AI is already being used in your organization, identify where your team may need guidance.
Pro tip: Use a risk levels table to facilitate your planning. Here’s an example:
AI Use
Risk Level
Guidance
Brainstorming email subject lines
Low
Usually acceptable with review
Drafting a fundraising appeal using general campaign details
Medium
Must carefully review
Uploading donor lists, payment information, or private notes
High
Avoid unless using an approved, secure tool
Using AI to make final decisions about services, recruiting, or donor priority
High
Requires strict oversight or should be prohibited
2. Protect donor and organizational data
As a nonprofit, you have access to a plethora of confidential information.
Safeguarding the information of your donors and organization is essential for responsible AI usage and maintaining your credibility.
As a rule, your team shouldn’t enter the following information into unapproved AI tools:
If you’re uncertain about whether certain information is safe to share with AI tools, here’s a helpful rule:
If the relevant information would not be included in a public document, it shouldn’t be shared with an unapproved AI platform.
Consider these additional steps to protect sensitive information:
Maintain an approved list of AI tools for organizational use.
Deeply investigate the privacy and data retention settings of the AI tools you use.
Train your staff to recognize confidential information before approving AI usage.
Carefully review compliance and security standards before adopting any AI tools.
What to look for when choosing an AI tool for your nonprofit
Before adopting and approving an AI tool, use the following checklist to determine whether it’s suitable enough to use internally:
Data privacy: Will sensitive information stay protected, where applicable?
Security certifications: Does the software provider comply with industry-leading security standards like SOC 2 and ISO 27001?
Data retention: Does the provider explain how long it stores your data and whether it uses your inputs to train its AI models?
Access controls: Can you restrict access to the tool and the information entered into it?
Integration requirements: Can you connect it with your existing CRM, fundraising platform, or other relevant software?
Vendor transparency: Does the provider clearly explain its AI capabilities, limitations, security practices, and data policies?
In addition, assess each AI tool based on what you’d like to accomplish with it while keeping in mind the sensitivity of the information involved.
3. Keep humans responsible for AI-assisted work
As I advised before, use AI to drive productivity and efficiency, not replace human expertise.
Allocate specific responsibilities to team members to maintain responsible AI practices.
However your organization uses – or plans to use – AI, make sure any content generated by AI is reviewed to maintain your brand’s tone of voice, consistency, and overall accuracy. AI-generated content should also align with your mission and comply with any legal or ethical standards.
AI is infamous for spouting inaccuracies with confidence.
For example, imagine asking AI to write an emergency appeal after a natural disaster and receiving a draft that contains unverified claims or exaggerates the scale of the damage. If shared publicly without any fact-checking done by a human, that could mislead donors and damage your organization’s reputation.
Always treat AI-generated content as a first draft and hold humans responsible for the finished product.
Sample AI governance scorecard for nonprofits
In addition to maintaining human oversight, use the following metrics to evaluate whether the guardrails you’ve put in place are effective, and where to improve.
What to Measure
What Good Governance Looks Like
Suggested Benchmark
Staff AI training coverage
Track the number of staff using AI who have completed training and understand your organization's acceptable-use policy.
100%
Approved tool compliance
Record how many AI tools in use have passed your organization's privacy, security, and data-retention checks.
100%
Content accuracy
Audit a sample of AI-assisted communications each quarter and track the percentage requiring factual corrections before human review and publication.
Decreasing over time
Privacy incidents
Track AI-related data exposure incidents (if any) and monitor whether repeat incidents decrease.
Zero incidents
Human oversight
Record the percentage of high-risk AI-assisted decisions that have documented human review and approval before action is taken.
100%
How to use this scorecard: Review these metrics quarterly with your team and board members. Compare the results against previous quarters, identify and look into any recurring gaps, and assign responsibility for corrective measures. Remember to update your internal AI policies and staff training based on your findings.
How to disclose AI use
New research shows that 76% of donors say it’s important that nonprofits clearly disclose when and how they use AI. Still, only 26% of nonprofit professionals say their organization does this.
Share how your organization incorporates AI in your everyday work with donors to instill trust and maintain transparency.
Here are a few sample AI disclosure statements you can adapt:
Fundraising emails: “This email was drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our team before sending.”
Campaign materials: “AI tools assisted in creating and editing this campaign content. All information regarding our programs and impact has been verified by our team.”
Annual reports: “We used AI tools to help organize and summarize certain information in this report. Our team reviewed the content for accuracy.”
AI-generated images: “This image was generated using AI for illustrative purposes and does not depict an actual beneficiary, event, or situation.”
4. Create an AI policy for your team
Having a formal AI policy in place sets clear expectations and gives your staff the confidence to leverage it efficiently.
You don’t need a lengthy or excessive policy to start out. The most important thing is that it clearly communicates and establishes consistent principles everyone can follow.
Ready-to-use nonprofit AI policy template
Download the helpful AI policy template below to get started – then adapt it accordingly to align with your organization’s needs.
Over to You
AI can help streamline your nonprofit operations and strengthen your fundraising, but it must always be used with care. A clear AI usage policy gives your team the structure to use these tools confidently and responsibly.
From there, it’s about choosing tools that support your fundraising work. Donorbox is committed to building features that help you do just that.
For example, Donorbox’s Jay·AI is a virtual, 24/7 fundraising assistant available to Pro and Premium users, and included with Donorbox CRM (coming soon). With a quick prompt, Jay helps you sort and pull donation and donor information, generate insightful reports, and write compelling fundraising copy.
Ready to start fundraising smarter? Sign up for Donorbox today.
Jamy-Lee has over 7 years of experience in copywriting and content marketing. With experience teaching in underserved communities and volunteering for animal rescue organizations, she has a first-hand understanding of the challenges faced by mission-driven organizations. She now uses her passion for writing to share practical insights that help nonprofits fulfill their missions.